With the Major League Baseball Amateur Draft on the horizon, this is the first of two articles looking at the Twins’ most recent drafts. This part looks at the first round picks of the last fifteen years and how they are faring (or have fared) in professional baseball. Next week I will look at the Twins minor leagues and how the draft has been used to stock the Twins system.
In the last 15 years, the Twins have drafted 22 players (including the supplemental first round). Of those 22, they have signed 20 of them (91%). They have drafted 9 pitchers, although recently there has been a larger focus at that position as five of the last eight first round picks have been pitchers. 4 outfielders and 3 catchers have also been drafted in the first round by the Twins.
Ten of these players have already made their major league debut with the Minnesota Twins, while eight more remain in the farm system awaiting their chance. That leaves two players (B. J. Garbe ’99 and Ryan Mills ’98) who never made it to the major league level after being drafted in the first round by the Twins. Incidentally, The Twins current roster (and disabled list) contains four of their first round picks (Hunter, Cuddyer, Mauer, and Perkins).
Of the ten players who have made it to the bigs, Matt Garza and Adam Johnson were the fastest, reaching the majors in their second season in the Twins organization. The average time from draft to debut was 3.8 years for those ten picks.
To satisfy all your curiosity, here are some words and numbers about each of the Twins first round draft picks in the last 15 years:
|2006 – Chris Parmelee – (20th overall – OF)
currently with Beloit (A)
Parmelee turned heads with his fast start last year. He hit 8 home runs in 45 games last year at the Rookie level before a late promotion to Beloit. Overall he hit .273/.369/.500 last year which resulted in his being listed as the #94 prospect in Baseball America’s top 100 prospects of 2007. So far this year, he’s hit .226/.305/.374 at Beloit with two home runs. Some eyebrows have been raised by his high strikeout total (38 SO in 115 AB) but he’s only 19 years old, so he’s still got plenty of time to develop. His mix of patience and power are the attributes that lead to the Twins selecting him in the first round.
|2005 – Matt Garza – (25th overall – P)
currently with Rochester (AAA) – 1 ML season
Garza’s unbelievably fast rise through the farm system last year caught a lot of attention, and he was ranked #21 in Baseball America’s top 100 prospects of 2007. He began last season with Fort Myers and pitched his way to promotions to New Britain and then Rochester, and finally, Minnesota. In nine starts with the Twins, Garza pitched 50 innings, allowing 32 earned runs (5.76 ERA) while striking out 6.8 per nine innings. He began the 2007 season at Rochester and is currently boasting a 3.86 ERA with 8.4 K/9 through his first nine starts. It’s only a matter of time until Garza dons a Twins uniform again.
|2005 – Henry Sanchez – (39th overall – 1B)
currently with Elizabethton (Rookie), 3rd minor league season
Sanchez was drafted out of high school and spent some time at Beloit last year. That stint, combined with his time in rookie ball gives a career line of .211/.274/.351 coming into this year. Sanchez is currently recovering from an injury, and so I couldn’t find any stats from this season. It doesn’t seem like he’s on the fast track right now, but only time will tell.
|2004 – Trevor Plouffe – (20th overall – SS)
currently with New Britain (AA), 4th minor league season
Drafted out of high school as the first of 5 first-round picks for the Twins in 2004, Plouffe has spent the last two seasons at A level before his promotion this year. In the previous three seasons he has hit .244/.321/.353. So far this season, Plouffe has hit .250/.306/.402 with the uptick in power due mostly to an increased number of doubles (11 2B out of 33 hits). Plouffe’s defense has also been improved according to scouts, which adds to the overall optimistic picture for this prospect.
|2004 – Glen Perkins – (22nd overall – P)
currently with Minnesota Twins, 2nd ML season
After being drafted from the University of Minnesota, Perkins made his debut in the stretch run for the Twins last season and was called up early this season, where he stayed until a recent injury put him on the disabled list. In those two stints, Perkins has 16 appearances, all out of the bullpen, with an ERA of 3.38, a 1.19 WHIP, and 6.75 K/9. In the minors, Perkins moved quickly, never spending more than one year at any level. He started 60 games while posting an ERA of 3.36, a 1.24 WHIP, and 9.63 K/9
|2004 – Kyle Waldrop – (25th overall – P)
currently with New Britain (AA), 4th minor league season
Waldrop was recently promoted to New Britain after getting off to a good start this year. In eight starts, he averaged 5.5 IP, had an ERA of 2.86 while striking out 41 in 44 innings. His first start at AA also looked good, as Waldrop allowed one earned run in seven innings. Since signing with the Twins, he has spent a year at rookie ball, followed by two years split betwixt Beloit and Fort Myers at the A level. In his minor league care
|2004 – Matthew Fox – (35th overall – P)
currently with Beloit (A), 3rd minor league season
Originally drafted, but not signed, in 2001 by the Arizona Diamondbacks, Fox attended the University of Central Florida before being drafted by the Twins. 2007 represents his first season above rookie level due to a injury to his labrum which took his 2005 season. He’s only appeared in one game thus far this year as he spent time at extended spring training, but he did pitch a scoreless inning in that appearance.
|2004 – Jay Rainville – (39th overall – P)
currently with Fort Myers (A), 3rd minor league season
Jay Rainville was drafted out of high school and began with one season at the rookie level, followed by parts of a season with Beloit and Fort Myers. In those two seasons, his ERA was 3.06 and his WHIP was 1.20. He would miss the entire 2006 season with an arm injury before returning this year where he left off, at Fort Myers. Rainville has eight starts this season for the Miracle, he has a 3.22 ERA in those starts with a 1.27 WHIP while averaging 4.5 IP/start.
|2003 – Matt Moses – (21st overall – 3B)
currently with Rochester (AAA), 5th minor league season
The Twins drafted Moses out of high school, and he spent a little more than a season at each level through the Twins system hitting .261/.323/.402 over the last four seasons. This is his first year at AAA, and he’s hitting .244/.264/.341. On a positive note Moses posted his highest home run total last season at New Britain (15, 31.6 AB/HR) which is a good sign for one of the Twins power hitting prospects.
|2002 – Denard Span – (20th overall – OF)
currently with Rochester (AAA), 5th minor league season
Span has long been tagged as Torii Hunter’s successor in centerfield for the Twins. Due to Mr. Hunter, Span hasn’t progressed to the majors as quickly as others on this list, but in his four previous seasons in the minors (none above AA), he has hit .288/.359/.346 while stealing 76 bases in about 1600 plate appearances. In his first season at AAA this year, Span is hitting .226/.282/.299 with 10 stolen bases.
|2001 – Joe Mauer – (1st pick overall – C)
currently with Minnesota Twins, 4th ML season, .323/.403/.472
Mauer started the season with the Twins in 2004 after the departure of A. J. Pierzynski. Unfortunately, due to injury, he would only appear in 35 games that year. Since then, Mauer has become a hitting machine, he won the batting title last season and posted a career high average (.347) and OBP (.446). Last year, Mauer won numerous accolades, including the Silver Slugger Award, an All-Star selection, and he garnered enough votes to place 6th in the AL MVP race. Mauer is currently on the disabled list with a leg injury but prior to that was still hitting well (.353/.446/.480).
|2000 – Adam Johnson – (2nd overall – P)
2 major league seasons, 10.25 ERA, 2.05 WHIP
Johson shot through the minor leagues, reaching the Majors after short stops at A, AA, and AAA in 2001. He would appear in seven games for the major league club including four starts, posting an 8.28 ERA and a 1.8 WHIP. After spending 2002 at AAA, Johnson made another brief appearance with the Twins in 2003, appearing in two games, pitching 1.1 innings and allowing eight runs. After another season in the minors, Johnson was released by Twins in 2005 and signed by the Oakland A’s. After a couple of seasons in the Oakland farm system, Johnson is out of professional baseball.
|1999 – B. J. Garbe – (5th overall – OF)
6 minor league seasons
Garbe was drafted out of high school by the Twins and spent two years each at the A and AA levels of the Twins organization. He hit .218/.298/.294 in those four seasons before he was traded in 2004 for Pat Borders. Garbe spent time in the Mariners and Marlins farm systems until 2006, but I couldn’t find a current team for him this season.
|1998 – Ryan Mills – (6th overall – P)
7 minor league seasons
Mills was originally drafted by the Yankees in the 13th round of the 1995 draft, but instead attended Arizona State University until the Twins drafted him in the first round. Mills would spend about two years at each level of the minors (as a starter at A and AA; and in the bullpen at AAA) but didn’t excel at any of them, as he posted a record of 17-40 with an ERA of 5.79 and a WHIP of 1.73 while walking 5.9 batters per nine innings. After 2004, the Twins released Mills and he hasn’t resurfaced anywhere else that I can find.
|1997 – Michael Cuddyer – (9th overall – SS/1B/2B/3B/OF)
currently with Minnesota Twins, 7th ML season, .269/.341/.454
Cuddyer had his breakout year last year when he hit 41 doubles and 24 home runs with a .284/.362/.504 line. It’s probably not coincidental that last season marked the first time Cuddyer played more than 95 games at any one position (142 games in right field). He made his debut in 2001, but spent significant time in the minors each of the next three seasons.
|1997 – Matt LeCroy – (50th overall – C)
currently with Rochester (AAA) – 7 ML seasons
The Mets drafted LeCroy initially in 1994, but he went to Clemson University instead for three seasons before the Twins drafted him. LeCroy made his debut with the Twins in 2000 and played six seasons with the Twins before he was granted free agency after the 2005 season. In those six seasons, LeCroy hit .275/.346/.460 with the Twins while averaging about 240 plate appearances per year. His best year was 2003 (coincidentally the year he got the most at-bats) when he hit 17 home runs while posting a line of .287/.342/.490. After a year in Washington, LeCroy returned to the Twins in the off-season as a free agent and is currently hitting .197/.256/.291 at AAA Rochester.
|1996 – Travis Lee – (2nd overall – 1B – did not sign)
9 year ML career, .256/.337/.408
|1995 – Mark Redman – (13th overall – P)
currently with Atlanta Braves, 9th ML season
Redman spent time with the Twins in three seasons from 1999 to 2001. However, the only consistent action he saw was in 2000, when he started 24 games and posted an ERA of 4.76, 7.0 K/9, and a 1.41 WHIP, which was good enough to place him 6th in the AL Rookie of the Year voting. Those numbers only differ from his career numbers in the frequency of strikeouts (5.5 career K/9, 4.75 ERA, 1.42 WHIP). He was traded to the Detroit Tigers at the deadline of the next year for Todd Jones. After leaving the Twins, Redman has been named an All-Star once (’06 with Kansas City) and won a World Series (’03 with Florida).
|1994 – Todd Walker – (8th overall – 2B)
currently with Oakland Athletics, 12th ML season
Walker made his debut with the Twins in 1996 and spent four seasons with the Twins, including a spectacular 1998 season where he posted career highs in BA (.316), OBP (.372) and OPS+ (119). In his Twins tenure, he hit .285/.341/.413 which corresponds with his career line of .289/.348/.435. He was traded to Colorado for another Todd, Todd Sears, in July of 2000.
|1993 – Torii Hunter – (20th overall – OF)
currently with Minnesota Twins, 11th ML season, .271/.324/.469
Hunter has patrolled center field for the Twins for the better part of the last nine seasons. In that time, his best performance to date was the 2002 season when he hit .289/.334/.524, won a start in the All-Star game, and came in 6th in the AL MVP voting. This year Hunter is demolishing all those numbers hitting an astronomical .318/.353/.611 so far. Hunter has also won six Gold Gloves and has been widely regarded as one of the best defensive centerfielders in the game.
|1993 – Jason Varitek – (21st overall – C – did not sign)
currently with Boston Red Sox, 11th ML season, .269/.349/.449
2-time All-Star (’03, ’05), Silver Slugger (2005), World Series (2004)
|1992 – Dan Serafini – (26th overall – P)
six major league seasons
Serafini had a six year career in the major leagues starting with three seasons with the Twins from 1996 to 1998 before his contract was purchased by the Chicago Cubs. With the Twins Serafini appeared in 35 games and for a couple stretches filled in as a starter. He started 14 games, posting a 5.45 ERA while averaging 5.1 innings per start with a 1.57 WHIP and 4.7 K/9 in those games. Overall with the Twins, Serafini posted a 5.88 ERA and a 1.67 WHIP.
Enormous thanks to TwinsCards.com, which is where I found all these images.